When the weather is this “nesh,” there is only one cure: Yorkshire Puddings.

This week, a massive debate kicked off on the Sheffield Reddit community about where to find the absolute best Sunday Roast in the city. Arguments were had, friendships were tested, but a few names kept coming up.
If you haven’t booked a table for tomorrow yet, here are the 5 spots the locals are raving about.
1. The Broadfield (Abbeydale Road)
The Vibe: Cosy, bustling, and reliable. The Verdict: Consistently voted the heavyweight champion. Their pies are legendary, but the roast beef (served pink, obviously) is what keeps the queues out the door.
- Insider Tip: Book weeks in advance. Seriously.
2. The Wisewood Inn (Loxley)
The Vibe: Proper pub, proper views. The Verdict: Famous for its “giant” Yorkshire puddings and serving Loxley Brewery ales. It’s the perfect reward after a freezing walk in the Loxley Valley.
3. The Beer Engine (Highfield)
The Vibe: Craft beer haven with a killer kitchen. The Verdict: A dark horse that’s rapidly becoming a favourite. Their veggie/vegan roasts get as much praise as the meat options, which is rare. Plus, the gravy is basically liquid gold.
4. Silversmiths (City Centre)
The Vibe: Upmarket Yorkshire dining. The Verdict: If you want your roast a bit “fancy,” this is the one. No piled-high plates here, just incredible quality local produce and the best roast potatoes in the city centre.
5. The Itchy Pig (Broomhill)
The Vibe: Micro-pub with big flavours. The Verdict: A mention for their pork roast (naturally). It’s intimate, friendly, and feels like eating in your mate’s very well-stocked living room.
Agree? Disagree? Did your favourite get snubbed? Head over to our directory, find your favourite pub, and leave them a 5-star review to boost them up the rankings!
0 Comments